Skip to content
SUS Farms — Allegedly Organic
← Back to Utah GardeningDownload PDF

pests · intermediate · 5-min read

Deer fencing that actually works

A determined Utah mule deer can clear a 7-foot fence from a standstill. Repellent sprays work for 2–4 weeks at a time, in dry weather, until they don't. The two strategies that consistently work long-term are 8-foot fence or the double-fence trick.

The 60-second version

Key takeaways

  • 01.Scout weekly — catch problems at week one, not week four
  • 02.Floating row cover excludes most flying insects
  • 03.Identify before treating — half of "pest" damage is environmental
  • 04.Encourage beneficials: lacewings, ladybugs, parasitic wasps

Section 1

The 8-foot fence

Black plastic deer netting on metal T-posts. 8 feet tall, posts every 10 feet. Cheap (under $1.50/ft), nearly invisible from 30 feet away, lasts 5–7 years before UV degrades it. Tension top and bottom wires keep it from sagging. Bury or stake the bottom edge — deer will push under a slack fence.

Section 2

The double-fence trick

Two parallel 4-foot fences, set 4 feet apart. Deer can clear height OR distance, but not both at once. The visual depth confuses the jump calculation. Cheaper than 8-foot fencing (regular field fencing works), and you can plant the gap between fences with non-tasty perennials so the strip looks intentional.

Section 3

Garden-only protection

Don't fence the whole yard — fence the vegetable garden. 4×8 raised beds with hoops + bird netting work for spring lettuce. A 6-foot dog kennel panel system makes a portable garden cage. Deer mostly leave thorny and aromatic perennials alone — site lavender, rosemary, and barberry between deer-favorites and the property edge.

Section 4

Repellent sprays — limited use

Bobbex, Liquid Fence, and Plantskydd work for 2–4 weeks before reapplication. Best for short-term protection of new transplants in fall. Rotate brands every reapplication so deer don't adapt. Useless after rain. Useless on plants you're going to eat.

Section 5

Plants deer mostly leave alone

Lavender, rosemary, sage, thyme, oregano, mint, daffodils, alliums, peonies, bleeding heart, bee balm, columbine, foxglove, lupine, yarrow, salvia, Russian sage. "Deer-resistant" is not "deer-proof" — a hungry deer in February will eat anything not on a list of toxic plants.

Tools & materials

What you’ll actually need

The shopping list. Everything below earns its place — we wouldn’t list a tool we don’t actually use on the farm.

Floating row cover (medium weight)

Excludes most flying insects without blocking enough light to slow growth. 7-foot rolls cover 4-foot beds.

Pheromone traps (codling moth, others)

Catch is your trigger to time sprays. Without traps you're guessing.

Bt (Bacillus thuringiensis) spray

Kills caterpillars, harmless to almost everything else. The single best organic insecticide for hornworms and cabbage worms.

Spinosad spray

For thrips, leaf miners, fire ants. Use sparingly — affects bees if sprayed on flowers.

Hand pruners and a bucket of soapy water

For squash bug egg masses and aphid colonies. Pick, drop in soapy water, done.

Things we’ve done wrong

Common mistakes & how to avoid them

Each of these has cost us a season at some point. Easier to learn from someone else’s mess than your own.

1.

Spraying broad-spectrum insecticides reflexively

The fix:They kill the lacewings, ladybugs, and parasitic wasps that would otherwise control pests for free. Spot-treat with the lightest tool that works.

2.

Waiting for damage before scouting

The fix:By the time you see real damage, the pest population is 10x what it was a week earlier. Weekly scouting catches outbreaks at week one.

3.

Skipping rotation

The fix:Cabbage maggot, squash bug, and verticillium wilt all build up in soil. Rotate plant families on a 4-year cycle.

Common questions

Frequently asked

+How does Utah's climate affect deer fencing that actually works?

Utah is high, dry, alkaline, and seasonally extreme. Compared to the humid east-coast advice in most gardening books, we deal with shorter shoulder seasons, more intense summer sun and UV, lower humidity (faster water loss), and soils that lock up iron and zinc. Adjust east-coast guidance accordingly: more water-conscious, more shade in summer, more attention to soil pH.

+Where do I find Utah-specific research?

USU Extension (extension.usu.edu/yardandgarden/) maintains the deepest archive of Utah-specific plant research in the state. Their Master Gardener helpline answers homeowner questions free. The Utah Climate Center at climate.usu.edu publishes 30-year climate normals for nearly every weather station — useful for planning frost dates and water budgets.

+How long until I see results?

Depends on what you're measuring. Soil amendments take 1 full season to show effects (sulfur for pH takes 4-8 months). Pest exclusion shows immediately. New plantings need 2-3 seasons to establish before drought tolerance kicks in. The biggest win is consistency — small actions taken weekly outperform big once-a-year efforts.

+Can I do this on a small backyard, or do I need acreage?

Almost everything in this guide scales down. A 4×8 raised bed, a few containers on a deck, or even a single fruit tree in a side yard each benefit from the same principles as a working farm — they just operate at different volumes. Container gardening is its own art and is well-suited to renters and small spaces.

Sources:USU Extension — Wildlife Damage·SUS Farms field notes, Sevier County

Keep going

Related guides

IPM pest calendar — Utah

Which pest, which month, which crop. Drawn from USU's Pest Advisory.

Read →

Vole and gopher control

Hardware cloth in tree wells, traps, the right kind of grass control. Why poison bait creates more voles.

Read →

Pocket gophers vs your lawn

Trapping, exclusion fencing, and why repellent gimmicks waste money. The most common Utah lawn pest after grubs.

Read →